annshafer.com
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Consulting
  • The Curator's Choice Podcast
  • The Curator's Choice Episodes
  • Platemark Podcast
  • Platemark Episodes
  • HoP episode transcripts
  • News
  • Projects
  • CV
  • About

Musings on Art, Mostly Printmaking

Reproductive prints reward scrutiny: Masson after Mignard

6/14/2020

1 Comment

 

Ann Shafer

​One of the reasons I love Stanley William Hayter so much is that I adore the quality of line he gets with engraving. In this method the artist uses a burin, a handheld tool with a diamond-shaped tip, to cut into the copper; they push the tool forward to incise a line in the copper into which the ink will lay. It takes a lot of strength and control, but it rewards the hard work. I love the swell and taper, the strength, the crispness.
 
Hayter used engraving in a totally new way beginning in the 1930s. Prior to that the technique was used to reproduce the compositions of other artists. This type of print is known as a reproductive print. By these prints, the artist of the original composition could spread his designs far and wide, and the engraver could make a living. They were created by very talented engravers who devised a series of patterns of marks meant to mimic brushstrokes, fabric, hair, feathers, all the while in black and white. You can imagine that the advent of photography in the late 1830s killed this entire industry and engraving along with it. One hundred years later, Hayter revitalized the technique, but in a wholly new way.
 
Reproductive prints are the bastard stepchild of the already bastard stepchild of prints, making them the bottom of the barrel. They don't get a lot of respect, but there has been a growing interest in them in the last few decades. Maybe they will soon have their day in the spotlight.
 
I used to skim past these kinds of prints when going through solander boxes in the storeroom. They tended to be portrait after portrait of persons I didn't recognize or care about. They seemed trite, fussy, controlled, old fashioned, and are markedly different from the modernist prints of Hayter and the associated artists at Atelier 17. But as happens with prints, the more you slow down your looking, the more you see. As we used to say in the print room: "these reward scrutiny."
 
I had a chance today to paw through Tru Ludwig's copy of Anthony Griffith's monumental book, The Print Before Photography (EDIT: not Prints and Printmaking: An Introduction to the History and Techniques, as first reported). The book is impressive, and the images are drawn solely from the collection of the British Museum. Its endpapers are a detail of a reproductive engraving by Antoine Masson of a portrait of Henri de Lorraine, Count of Harcourt, by Nicolas Mignard from 1667. In the first few pages are more details plus the entire image. As you look through these details, check out how many different patterns are used and what they describe. This is when reproductive engravings get interesting for me: imagining an artist looking at a painting, or, more likely, a drawing of the painting, and attempting to render the flesh of the sitter's hand with black lines and dashes. Or the curling hair of his mustache. Or the shine of his satin sleeves. The list goes on. It truly boggles the mind.
 
Antoine Masson (French, 1636–1700), after Nicolas Mignard (French, 1606–1668)
Henri de Lorraine, Count of Harcourt, 1667
Engraving
Plate (trimmed within platemark) 544 x 390 (20 1/2 x 16 in.)
British Museum: Bequest of Clayton Mordaunt Cracherode, R,6.209
Picture of Nicolas Mignard's engraved portrait of the Count of Harcourt, 1667
Antoine Masson (French, 1636–1700), after Nicolas Mignard (French, 1606–1668). Henri de Lorraine, Count of Harcourt, 1667. Engraving, plate (trimmed within platemark) 544 x 390 (20 1/2 x 16 in.). British Museum: Bequest of Clayton Mordaunt Cracherode, R,6.209
Picture of a detail from Nicolas Mignard's engraved portrait of the Count of Harcourt, 1667
DETAIL: Antoine Masson (French, 1636–1700), after Nicolas Mignard (French, 1606–1668) Henri de Lorraine, Count of Harcourt, 1667 Engraving Plate (trimmed within platemark) 544 x 390 (20 1/2 x 16 in.) British Museum: Bequest of Clayton Mordaunt Cracherode, R,6.209
Picture of a detail from Nicolas Mignard's engraved portrait of the Count of Harcourt, 1667
DETAIL: Antoine Masson (French, 1636–1700), after Nicolas Mignard (French, 1606–1668) Henri de Lorraine, Count of Harcourt, 1667 Engraving Plate (trimmed within platemark) 544 x 390 (20 1/2 x 16 in.) British Museum: Bequest of Clayton Mordaunt Cracherode, R,6.209
Picture of a detail from Nicolas Mignard's engraved portrait of the Count of Harcourt, 1667
DETAIL: Antoine Masson (French, 1636–1700), after Nicolas Mignard (French, 1606–1668) Henri de Lorraine, Count of Harcourt, 1667 Engraving Plate (trimmed within platemark) 544 x 390 (20 1/2 x 16 in.) British Museum: Bequest of Clayton Mordaunt Cracherode, R,6.209
Picture of a detail from Nicolas Mignard's engraved portrait of the Count of Harcourt, 1667
DETAIL: Antoine Masson (French, 1636–1700), after Nicolas Mignard (French, 1606–1668) Henri de Lorraine, Count of Harcourt, 1667 Engraving Plate (trimmed within platemark) 544 x 390 (20 1/2 x 16 in.) British Museum: Bequest of Clayton Mordaunt Cracherode, R,6.209
Picture
DETAIL: Antoine Masson (French, 1636–1700), after Nicolas Mignard (French, 1606–1668) Henri de Lorraine, Count of Harcourt, 1667 Engraving Plate (trimmed within platemark) 544 x 390 (20 1/2 x 16 in.) British Museum: Bequest of Clayton Mordaunt Cracherode, R,6.209
Picture of a detail from Nicolas Mignard's engraved portrait of the Count of Harcourt, 1667
DETAIL: Antoine Masson (French, 1636–1700), after Nicolas Mignard (French, 1606–1668) Henri de Lorraine, Count of Harcourt, 1667 Engraving Plate (trimmed within platemark) 544 x 390 (20 1/2 x 16 in.) British Museum: Bequest of Clayton Mordaunt Cracherode, R,6.209
Picture of a detail from Nicolas Mignard's engraved portrait of the Count of Harcourt, 1667
DETAIL: Antoine Masson (French, 1636–1700), after Nicolas Mignard (French, 1606–1668) Henri de Lorraine, Count of Harcourt, 1667 Engraving Plate (trimmed within platemark) 544 x 390 (20 1/2 x 16 in.) British Museum: Bequest of Clayton Mordaunt Cracherode, R,6.209
Picture of a detail from Nicolas Mignard's engraved portrait of the Count of Harcourt, 1667
DETAIL: Antoine Masson (French, 1636–1700), after Nicolas Mignard (French, 1606–1668) Henri de Lorraine, Count of Harcourt, 1667 Engraving Plate (trimmed within platemark) 544 x 390 (20 1/2 x 16 in.) British Museum: Bequest of Clayton Mordaunt Cracherode, R,6.209
Picture of a detail from Nicolas Mignard's engraved portrait of the Count of Harcourt, 1667
DETAIL: Antoine Masson (French, 1636–1700), after Nicolas Mignard (French, 1606–1668) Henri de Lorraine, Count of Harcourt, 1667 Engraving Plate (trimmed within platemark) 544 x 390 (20 1/2 x 16 in.) British Museum: Bequest of Clayton Mordaunt Cracherode, R,6.209
1 Comment
GREGORY MOST
6/18/2020 09:45:22 pm

While it is possible that reproductive prints are the bastard stepchild of the less than legitimate print - at least as perceived by many print curators and enthusiasts - photography did not kill this incredible medium of reproducing artwork quickly. The once common date for the birth of photography was given as 1839 (now perhaps earlier depending on whom you read) but engraving of works of art continued into the early 20th century, killed like so many people, by World War I. Many early publishers would replicate reproductive prints since cameras were still unable to capture works of art in available light (e.g. Franz Hanfstaengl in Dresden who replicated his earlier commission of published reproductive prints of the royal collection with photos of the prints in 1860).

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Ann's art blog

    A small corner of the interwebs to share thoughts on objects I acquired for the Baltimore Museum of Art's collection, research I've done on Stanley William Hayter and Atelier 17,  experiments in intaglio printmaking, and the Baltimore Contemporary Print Fair.

    Archives

    May 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    October 2021
    August 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020

    Categories

    All
    Albrecht Durer
    Alison Saar
    Alternate Realities
    American Modernism
    Amy Cutler
    Amze Emmons
    Andrew Raftery
    An-My Le
    Annalise Gratovich
    Ann Hamilton
    Ann Shafer
    Antoine Masson
    Ants
    Aquatint
    Art
    Art History
    Artist's Books
    Asa Cheffetz
    Astrid Bowlby
    Atelier 17
    Atelier Contrepoint
    Baltimore Museum Of Art
    Baptiste Debombourg
    Bill Thompson
    B.J.O. Nordfeldt
    Carolina Nitsch
    Carrie Mae Weems
    Caspar David Friedrich
    Cassandre
    Catalyst Contemporary
    Charles Demuth
    Charles Gaines
    Charles White
    Chitra Ganesh
    Claude Flight
    Claude Mellan
    Claude Monet
    Clinton Blair King
    Crown Point Press
    CRW Nevinson
    Curator
    Curator's Choice
    Cyril Power
    Damon Arhos
    Damon Davis
    Dario Robleto
    David Avery
    Deb Sokolow
    Denise Tassin
    Derrick Adams
    Desiree Hayter
    Diana Scultori
    Diane Victor
    Diego Velasquez
    Drawing
    Drypoint
    Durer
    Earthworms
    Edgar Allen Poe
    Edouard Manet
    Edward Hopper
    Elisabetta Sirani
    Ellen MacNary
    Engraving
    Enrique Chagoya
    Ernst Ludwig Kirchner
    Etc
    Etching
    Etching Revival
    Evan Lindquist
    Excudit
    Félix Bracquemond
    Felix-Hilaire Buhot
    Fiona Banner
    Force: Upsetting Rape Culture
    Fred Becker
    Full Circle
    Gabor Peterdi
    Gallery Neptune & Brown
    Geertruydt Roghman
    Grosvenor School
    Harry Belafonte
    Hector Saunier
    Hendrick Goltzius
    Horst Janssen
    Intaglio
    Iona Rozeal Brown
    Jacob Hashimoto
    James Barry
    James Siena
    James Stroud
    James Tissot
    Japonisme
    Jed Smalley
    Jim Dine
    John Alexander
    John Baldessari
    John Taylor Arms
    John White Abbott
    Jonathan Novack
    Joscelyn Gardner
    Joseph Hirsch
    Kathe Kollwitz
    Landscape
    Las Meninas
    Leo Katz
    Letterio Calapai
    Lill Tschudi
    Linoleum Cut
    Lithograph
    London
    London Original Print Fair
    Louis Auguste Lepere
    Lovis Corinth
    Ludovic Lepic
    Marchel Duchamp
    Marion MacPhee
    Mark Thomas Gibson
    Martin Lewis
    Martin Mazorra
    Martin Wilner
    Mary Cassatt
    Maurice Sanchez
    Max Beckman
    Max Klinger
    Michael Waugh
    Mixografia
    Monoprint
    Multiples
    Nicola Lopez
    Nicolas Mignard
    Oil
    Oil Painting
    Pace Prints
    Painting
    Parastou Forouhar
    Paul Fusco
    Paulson Fontaine Press
    Peter Blum
    Peter Milton
    Photograph
    Photogravure
    Picturesque
    Piet Mondrian
    Poster
    Press
    Print
    Printmaking
    Rachel Perry
    Raphaelle Peale
    Rashaad Newsome
    Raven Chacon
    Raymond Pettibon
    Reginald Marsh
    Rembrandt
    Richard Diebenkorn
    Richard Long
    Robert Hills
    Roderick Mead
    Romanticism
    Sascha Braunig
    Sculpsit
    Sculpture
    Sebastian Black
    Shahzia Sikander
    Sherrie Levine
    Shu-lin Chen
    Simultaneous Color Printing
    Slavery
    Stanley William Hayter
    Stan Shellabarger
    Steve DiBenedetto
    Sue Fuller
    Susan Harbage Page
    Susan Sheehan Gallery
    Tamarind Institute
    Tandem Press
    Tauba Auerbach
    Terron Sorrells
    The Multiple Store
    The Old Print Shop
    Thomas Thistlewood
    Toshio Sasaki
    Transferware
    Trenton Doyle Hancock
    Trisha Brown
    Tru Ludwig
    Turner
    Ursula Fookes
    Victoria & Albert
    Victoria Burge
    Viscosity
    Vladimir Cybil Charlier
    Walton Ford
    Wangechi Mutu
    Watercolor
    Watercolour
    Werner Drewes
    West Coast Print Fair
    Western Exhibitions
    Whitfield Lovell
    Wildwood Press
    William Kentridge
    William Villalongo
    Wingate Studio
    Woodblock Print
    Woodcut
    Wood Engraving
    Works On Paper
    Yinka Shonibare MBE
    Yukinori Yanagi
    Zilda

    RSS Feed

    GO TO TOP OF PAGE

      Sign up here for alerts.

    Subscribe to Newsletter

What our Platemark listeners are saying

Way up there in the podcast Top Ten, IMHO.  A great series and engaging leaders.
----- M.A.D.

Contact Us

    Subscribe Today!

Submit
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Consulting
  • The Curator's Choice Podcast
  • The Curator's Choice Episodes
  • Platemark Podcast
  • Platemark Episodes
  • HoP episode transcripts
  • News
  • Projects
  • CV
  • About